Categories
Podcasts

Crime, Comedy, and Karen & Georgia:

My Favorite Murder, Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark prove why they’ve become podcast royalty. With their signature blend of dark humor, heartfelt honesty, and chaotic energy, the duo delivers two chilling cases while keeping things oddly comforting. Whether they’re dissecting the suspicious death of Tamla Horsford or recounting the disturbing charm of Rodney Alcala, their chemistry and compassion shine through. It’s not just about the murders—it’s about surviving them, talking through them, and occasionally laughing in the dark.

Categories
Podcasts

Uncorking Crime:

Wine and Crime serves up a boozy blend of humor and homicide, where the hosts’ unapologetic sass and storytelling charm turn even the darkest cases into oddly delightful listens. While the wine pairings are playful, the podcast’s true strength lies in its ability to balance levity with respect for victims—a tricky line they walk with surprising grace.

Categories
Podcasts

Spooky Stories and Savage Sass:

Mandy and Avery aren’t just podcast hosts—they’re the best friends you didn’t know you needed in your true crime rotation. Episode 42 delivers everything fans love: spine-chilling stories, wild tangents, and unfiltered banter that makes even the darkest tales strangely comforting.

Categories
Podcasts

Murder, Mayhem, and Bestie Banter:

A Love Letter to Morbid The Morbid Podcast: A True Crime Cozy Sesh (With a Side of Sarcasm) If you haven’t yet wandered into the world of Morbid: A True Crime Podcast, allow me to set the scene. Imagine you’re hanging out in your favorite oversized hoodie, sipping coffee with two of your closest friends […]

Categories
Podcasts

Crime Junkie:

Crime Junkie has captivated millions with its gripping storytelling and binge-worthy cases, but does it hold up under scrutiny? While hosts Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat deliver chilling narratives, the podcast has faced criticism for lacking original research and ethical transparency. Does Crime Junkie truly respect the victims it covers, or is it just another case of true crime entertainment prioritizing drama over diligence? Let’s dive into the facts and uncover the truth

Categories
Podcasts

Unmasking Casefile:

If you love true crime that’s immersive, meticulously researched, and free of unnecessary banter, Casefile is a must-listen. This documentary-style podcast delivers gripping stories with chilling precision, narrated by an anonymous host whose calm demeanor only adds to the eerie atmosphere. With episodes that dive deep into every detail—from court records to forensic evidence—Casefile sets the gold standard for fact-based storytelling. However, its serious tone, lack of host interaction, and lengthy episodes may not be for everyone. Still, if you want a no-frills, high-quality crime podcast, this one should be at the top of your list.

Categories
Podcasts

Brotherly Terror:

The Brown Brothers Haunting Hour delivers an engaging mix of ghost stories, urban legends, and real-life supernatural encounters, all wrapped up in the easygoing banter of its two hosts. With solid research, immersive storytelling, and eerie atmosphere, the podcast keeps listeners hooked. However, occasional pacing issues and predictable structures leave room for growth. A few tweaks—like guest appearances and themed episodes—could push this show to the next level. Whether you’re a casual listener or a die-hard paranormal fan, this haunted hour is worth tuning into.

Categories
Podcasts Visual Podcast

“Prison, Powder, and Plot Twists: Bailey Sarian’s Best Yet?”

If you love true crime, a little bit of history, and a flawless smoky eye, then you’re probably already familiar with Bailey Sarian’s Murder, Mystery, & Makeup series. If not, let me introduce you to one of the internet’s most charismatic storytellers, who somehow makes learning about gruesome crimes feel like you’re just chatting with a best friend over coffee (or, in this case, while she blends out her contour). One episode that truly captures the essence of her unique approach is Jail Cell Justice—a deep dive into a crime that makes you rethink just how safe a jail cell really is.

Categories
Paranormal Podcasts

And That’s Why We Drink:

If you’re on the hunt for a podcast that delivers spine-tingling ghost stories and bone-chilling true crime tales with a generous side of laughter, look no further. ‘And That’s Why We Drink’ is like grabbing a drink with your two hilarious, slightly unhinged friends—except instead of gossip, you’re getting hauntings, murders, and a whole lot of tangents. Episode 127 is a prime example of their quirky, chaotic charm, making you feel like you’re in the room with them, laughing and shivering in equal measure

Categories
About Me!

Welcome to CrimeCast Critique

Welcome to CrimeCast Critique – Your Next Obsession Awaits!

Feel that chill? You’ve just stepped into CrimeCast Critique, your ultimate guide to the best (and worst) true crime podcasts. Whether you crave bone-chilling mysteries or deep investigative dives, I’m here to help you find your next obsession.

Expect eerie recommendations, brutally honest reviews, and a few surprises along the way—especially for those who stick around after my semester ends. What’s coming? You’ll have to wait and see…

So, double-check your locks, grab your detective’s notebook, and stay tuned. The truth is waiting.